The problems with the PTAB

By Adam Mossoff and David Lund

Five years of Patent Trial and Appeal Board proceedings show a flawed and biased administrative tribunal

Five years after the America Invents Act established the Patent Trial and Appeal Board (PTAB) at the US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), it is time to evaluate how this has negatively affected the patent system. The PTAB is an administrative tribunal that runs three new processes for invalidating patents: post-grant review, inter partes review and the temporary programme for review of covered business method patents. By design, the PTAB cancels property rights that the USPTO previously granted. According to its proponents, this was necessary to remove so-called ‘bad’ patents that had been erroneously issued by the USPTO. As a consequence, proponents argued that the PTAB would strengthen the patent system in its essential role of driving the innovation economy.

Want to read more?

Register to access two of our subscriber-only articles per month

Subscribe for unlimited access to articles, in-depth analysis and research from the IAM experts

Already registered? Log in

What our customers are saying

IAM explores how businesses can leverage IP rights as real assets beyond their traditional use. As the magazine addresses IP management issues without overly dwelling on legal matters, I consider it an eminently useful reference for innovative business executives.

Dr Frank Cuypers
Consulting actuary


Subscribe to receive access to the full range of premium business intelligence, insights and analysis, as well as our IP directories, guides and daily news.

Why subscribe?


Register for more free content

  • Read more IAM blogs and articles
  • Receive the editor's weekly review by email
Register now  
Issue 90